"City in the Desert: Volume 1 - The Monster Problem" Graphic Novel Review

 

Written by James Ferguson

 

Published by Archaia Entertainment

 

City In The Desert Volume 1 00

 

Written and Illustrated by Moro Rogers
2012, 148 Pages
Graphic Novel released on November 14th, 2012

 

Review:


Monster hunting is serious business and business is good for Irro Zaing-Marda.  Unfortunately, no one can afford to pay for the bounties that monster carcasses once brought in.  Now he's trying to scrap by with enough to feed himself and his monkey girl companion, Hari.  It wasn't always like this.  Long ago, monster hunters used to ride with the caravans across the desert, protecting them.  Now the caravans have dried up, but there are still plenty of beasts out there.

City in the Desert, the latest from writer / artist Moro Rogers, creates an interesting mythology right from the beginning.  Rogers comes up with everything, including how these people came into existence in the first place.  There was a god named Iriaze who created man.  One day, the Evil One tried to kill man and the blood spilled from their battle created the monsters that now hunt man.  Ages later, people still live in fear of these creatures, but there's a strange relationship between the two.  The beasts exist because of the sorrow of man that's sucked up into the sky to come back down again like rain.  It's an intriguing setup.

City In The Desert Volume 1 01City In The Desert Volume 1 02City In The Desert Volume 1 03City In The Desert Volume 1 04
Click images to enlarge

 

There is still much to explore in City in the Desert.  Rogers lays the groundwork with this first volume, entitled The Monster Problem.  You get the basic mythology down and understand how some of the things work.  These people have chosen to live in the middle of this barren wasteland as that is where the spirit fountain is.  No one knows what this thing does or why it's here, but it's important to them.  When a traveling priest comes to town and suggests closing the fountain to destroy the monsters, things get weird.  People start acting strange, like they don't care about anything.  

Rogers has a playful art style.  There are some serious issues brought up, but they never feel too scary as the artwork is light.  You could see this as a cartoon.  Even when blood is spilled or monsters are attacking, it doesn't feel like there's a real danger.  This took me out of the book a bit as it never felt like there were any serious consequences for the characters despite them facing death at times.  Rogers' artwork does make the book easier to read for a younger audience though.  

City In The Desert Volume 1 05City In The Desert Volume 1 06City In The Desert Volume 1 07City In The Desert Volume 1 08
Click images to enlarge

 

The Monster Problem ends just as things are getting interesting.  I understand that this is just the first volume and the next chapter, entitled The Serpent Crown, is coming soon, but I felt like I was left hanging when I finished this book.  It's not an ending.  It's like Rogers set up all the pieces on a gameboard and then knocked them all over just when we were about to start playing.  I'm interested enough to keep reading when the next volume comes out though, as there's definitely a unique story at work here.  I want to see where this is going.  I just wish it had been done in one book instead of (at least) two.


Grades:

 

 
Story: Threeandahalfstars City In The Desert Volume 1 Amazon UkCity In The Desert Volume 1 Amazon Us
Art: Threestars
Overall: Threestars

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

About The Author
Spez Bio 2
Lord of the Funny Books
James has a 2nd grade reading level and, as a result, only reads books with pictures. Horror is his 5th favorite genre right after romantic comedy and just before silent films. No one knows why he's here, but he won't leave.
Recent Articles

Search

Popular Categories

YouTube

OBEY - CONSUME

Contests

  • 1

Join Us!

Close

Hit the buttons below to follow us, you won't regret it...